Thursday 3 November 2011

witchcraft


The spread of Christianity throughout Europe in the Middle Ages resulted in a somewhat catastrophic purge of the insane under the guise of faith – the witch hunts, or “Burning Times” as modern Wiccans call it (Guiley, 2008; Lewis, 1999), the term having been coined by the 20th century Wiccan leader, Gerald Gardner (Golden, 2006; Simpson & Roud, 2000). 


Gerald Gardner

According to Millon (2004) and others (Mackay, 2009), medieval Christian mythology included a belief that there was a worldwide Satanic conspiracy to destroy Christianity (Bonewits, 2001; Mackay, 1841), and that the agents of this conspiracy were witches, who not only worshipped Satan (Gurses, 1997), but also engaged in other heinous activities including murder, cannibalism and sexual orgies (the anxiety over the latter being provoked by the sexual activities of some monks and nuns (Darton, 1999)). As a result of this misguided belief, the Inquisition (the Holy Office of the Inquisition of the Roman Catholic Church, established in 1188 by Pope Lucius III, to prevent the spread of heretical movements (Lewis, 1999; Nemec, 1974)) was informed in 1233 by Pope Gregory IX to root out witches, heretics and all other agents of the Evil One (Bailey, 2003a; Guiley, 2008; McBrien, 2006; Porter, 2002). Images of witches riding broomsticks first appeared in 1280 (Ellerbe, 1995). 


An early image of a witch on a broomstick

Pope Paul II, in 1468, declared witchcraft a “crimen exceptum” (Golden, 2006), thus giving ecclesiastical and secular courts complete freedom in dealing with witches (Nemec, 1974). Not only the leaders of Christianity believed this, but it was also taken on by the common people, and it was a belief still prevalent in the 17th century. The Old Testament was often quoted as a rationalisation for these beliefs, particularly Exodus xii, 18: “Thou shalt suffer no witch to live”. Zimmermann & Gleason (2000) opine that this passage was originally worded “Thou shalt not suffer a poisoner to live,” but that King James I, whose translation of the Bible is the commonly accepted version, was so scared of witches that he changed the wording to that given here. This is reinforced by Bonewits (2001) and Golden (2006). King James also wrote about witchcraft himself, publishing Daemonologie in 1597 (Guiley, 2008; James VI, 1597). 


James I of England

Both Catholics and Protestants believed that witches could invoke demons to possess others (Bailey, 2003b), and it was the duty of the church (in whatever form) to force those who were possessed by demons to admit to being witches and to deliver the names of other witches to the church. This admission was evinced by torture (Bailey, 2003b; Bonewits, 2001), and once elicited the punishment for being guilty was usually death, especially by burning at the stake (although the English Witchcraft Acts of the 16th century prescribed hanging as the penalty (Simpson & Roud, 2000)); however, it has to be said that the religious leaders who recommended such punishment would not have seen it as such – rather it was seen as a benevolent act that rid the victim of a possessing demon. 


The execution of witches by hanging

It could also be argued that the witchcraft delusion was the church’s paternalistic means of disempowering women (Al-Sharif, 2004; Ellerbe, 1995; Golden, 2006; Herzig, 2006; Jackson, 1995; Schuler, n.d.; Toivo, 2005), as more women than men were accused of being witches (between 75 and 90 percent of those convicted were female, depending on place and time (Bailey, 2003a; Bailey, 2003b; Ellerbe, 1995; Stearne, 1648)), yet the counter argument was that more men than women were bewitched (a situation that implies female power, anathema to the church). English witches in particular were often elderly women (Ellerbe, 1995; Fletcher, 1896) who depended on others for charity, and the thinking was that they were resentful of those who refused them such charity (Simpson & Roud, 2000), leading them to utter curses and other magical incantations (Gaskill, 2000).
In 1484 Pope Innocent VIII, in his bull Summis Desiderentes Affectibus, spoke out against witchcraft and exhorted the church to stamp the practice out, by whatever means necessary (Bailey, 2003b; Buckland, 1986; Campbell, 1986; Darton, 1999; Ellerbe, 1995; Flinn, 2007; Fulford, Thornton & Graham, 2006; Golden, 2006; Guiley, 2008; Gurses, 1997; Harrison, 1975; Hinshaw, 2007; Levack, 2004; Mackay, 2009; Maxwell-Stuart, 2001; Millon, 2004; Nemec, 1974; Summers, 1926; Tuke, 1892; Vandermeersch, 1991; Williams, 1865; Zimmermann & Gleason, 2000). 


Pope Innocent VIII

As a result two Dominican (the sect of monks that had come to administer the Inquisition (Bailey, 2003b; Golden, 2006; Lewis, 1999; Mackay, 2009)) friars, Johann Sprenger (1436-95) and Heinrich Kraemer (c.1430-1505) published Malleus Maleficarum (The Witches’ Hammer), a manual on the detection of witchcraft, the examination of witches and the legal sentencing of them, first published in 1486 (Bailey, 2003a; Bailey, 2003b; Bonewits, 2001; Buckland, 1986; Colp, 2000; Darton, 1999; Ellerbe, 1995; Fulford, Thornton & Graham, 2006; Golden, 2006; Guiley, 2008; Gurses, 1997; Harrison, 1975; Hinshaw, 2007; Hoyt, 1989; Kamen, 2000; Levack, 2004; Mackay, 1841; Mackay, 2009; Maxwell-Stuart, 2001; Millon, 2004; Nemec, 1974; Pugh, 2001; Vandermeersch, 1991; Williams, 1865; Zimmermann & Gleason, 2000). Examination of a person accused of witchcraft included a search for  “devil’s stigmata”, insensitive marks on the skin, such as red spots, ulcers, or depressions, which were considered proof of having had sexual relations with the Devil (Bailey, 2003b; Darton, 1999; Ellerbe, 1995; Fletcher, 1896; Golden, 2006; Guiley, 2008; Jones, 1972; Nemec, 1974; Notestein, 1911; Pugh, 2001; Summers, 1926; Williams, 1865). 


Malleus Maleficarum

In England the most notorious witch finder was Matthew Hopkins, who proclaimed himself the “Witchfinder-General” and travelled throughout the land, arranging executions of witches, particularly in East Anglia (Kamen, 2000; Mackay, 1841; Simpson & Roud, 2000) in 1645-6, resulting in the loss of over 200 lives (Bailey, 2003b; Guiley, 2008). Hopkins died in 1647, probably from tuberculosis (Stearne, 1648), but legend has it that he was accused of witchcraft himself and was hanged (Guiley, 2008; Kamen, 2000; Simpson & Roud, 2000).


Matthew Hopkins, Witchfinder-General

The Malleus Maleficarum served the Inquisition well and resulted in perhaps hundreds of thousands of innocent men and women put to death at the stake, or, in Britain, by hanging (Gaskill, 2000; Golden, 2006; Guiley, 2008; Hills, 1901; Lewis, 1999; Millon, 2004; Regis, 1894). Pet cats were often killed at the same time as their owner, as the belief was that the feline was a familiar who helped the witch in her evildoing (Bailey, 2003b; Ellerbe, 1995; Fletcher, 1896; Golden, 2006), although this practice appears to have been more prevalent on the mainland of Europe rather than the British Isles (Simpson & Roud, 2000). Gaskill (2000) suggests that many of the prosecutions for witchcraft ensued from personal feuds. Many of the successful prosecutions would have been of people with mental health problems (as mental illness was seen as being due to possession by demons) – easy prey to accusations of crop-spoiling, causing illness, shape-changing, controlling the weather, the “evil eye” and so forth (Bailey, 2003b; Guiley, 2008; Hills, 1901; Notestein, 1911), the sort of behaviours that witches were supposed to demonstrate. This is borne out by at least one writer of the time, Pierre Pigray of France who commented on an examination of fourteen people in 1589 in Paris:
We found them to be very poor, stupid people, and some of them insane; many of them were quite indifferent about life, and one or two of them desired death as a relief for their sufferings. Our opinion was, that they stood more in need of medicine than of punishment, and so we reported to the Parliament. Their case was, thereupon, taken into further consideration, and the Parliament, after mature counsel amongst all the members, ordered the poor creatures to be sent to their homes, without inflicting any punishment upon them. (Mackay, 1841, page 237).
British legislation reflected the Catholic church’s stance, and a series of Witchcraft Acts were passed between 1541 and 1735, the last of which banned the practice of judicial murder of those condemned as witches (Adams, 1889; Buckland, 1986; Dock, 1920; Gaskill, 2000; Golden, 2006; Guiley, 2008; Jones, 1972; Pugh, 2001; Williams, 1865) and suggested that claims of witchcraft were fraudulent. It was not until 1951 that the last Witchcraft Act was repealed (Buckland, 1986; Guiley, 2008; Levack, 2004). The last execution of a convicted “witch” was in 1782 (Golden, 2006; Millon, 2004), and the last known trial for witchcraft took place in Poland in 1793 (Nemec, 1974). The last execution of a witch in Britain was in 1727 in Scotland (Guiley, 2008; Levack, 2004; Pugh, 2001; Tuke, 1882).
Not everyone agreed with the purge. For example, in 1460, Dominican monk and professor of logic at the University of Milan, Girolamo Visconti (Golden, 2006), admitted in his book on witchcraft that “many men of learning and authority think that these [witches’] illusions arise from a melancholic humor, depriving women of reason and free will.”
The Dutch physician Johann Weyer (1515-88) also wrote against the persecutions (Bailey, 2003b; Colp, 2000; Darton, 1999; Golden, 2006; Guiley, 2008; Maxwell-Stuart, 2001; Porter, 2002; Millon, 2004; Slattery, 1994; Vandermeersch, 1991; Williams, 1865) in his De Praestigiis Daemonum et Incantationibus ac Venificiis (On the Illusions of the Demons and on Spells and Poisons), published in 1563. (Sigmund Freud ranked this book among the ten most important he had read (Golden, 2006)). He believed that melancholy (insanity) caused many delusions and hysterical “imaginings,” and that  “magicians” and “diabolists” were actually the victims of hysteria or hypochondriasis (Golden, 2006; Kamen, 2000; Levack, 2004; Nemac, 1974). He also stated that “Witches’ experiences are delirious dreams induced by drugs.” This is pertinent when one considers the so-called flying ointments of witches. These included extracts from various hallucinogenic plants (Lewis, 1999), including aconite, belladonna, hemlock, henbane, wormwood, and mandrake (Bever, 2008; Golden, 2006; Guiley, 2008; Harrison,1975; Hoyt, 1989; Simpson & Roud, 2000; Summers, 1926). Furthermore, the ointment was said to have been applied to broom handles (Bailey, 2003b), which were then inserted vaginally such that the active alkaloids present in the ointment were absorbed through the mucous membranes. This practice gave rise to the belief that witches rode broomsticks (Golden, 2006; Guiley, 2008; Harrison, 1975; Pollan, 2001). Weyer has also been recognized as the first writer to state that suicide is often a manifestation of despair (Rush, 1988). Because of his antithesis to the witchcraft craze, Weyer’s book was proscribed by the Catholic church, and Weyer himself was accused of sorcery (Darton, 1999; James VI, 1597).


Johann Weyer

A third author who spoke out against the witch trials was the Englishman Reginald Scot (1538-1599) in his The Discoverie of Witchcraft, which was published in 1584 (Bailey, 2003b; Golden, 2006; Guiley, 2008; Gurses, 1997; Levack, 2004; Maxwell-Stuart, 2001; Porter, 2002; Scot, 1584; Simpson & Roud, 2000; Williams, 1865). He stated: Alas, I am sorry and ashamed to see how many die who being said to be bewitched, only seek for magical cures, whom wholesome diet and good medicines would have recovered. . . These affections tho' they appear in the mind of man, yet are they bred in the body and proceed from the humour which is the very dregs of the blood; nourishing those places from whence proceed fear, cogitations, superstitions, fastings, labours, and such like.
Shakespeare used Scot’s book as a resource, and James I ordered the book to be burned (Bailey, 2003b; Guiley, 2008; Gurses, 1997; James VI, 1597; Kamen, 2000; Simpson & Roud, 2000).
The American colonies did not react as quickly, and in 1692 a hundred and fifty supposed witches were tried in Salem, Masschusetts, with nineteen hanged (Elder, Evans & Nizette, 2005; Golden, 2006; Guiley, 2008; Maxwell-Stuart, 2001). Later authors have theorised that the symptoms displayed by these so-called witches were in fact due to ergotism (Guiley, 2006).


The Salem witchcraft trial

References:

Adams, W.H.D. (1889). Witch, warlock and magician: historical sketches of magic and witchcraft in England and Scotland. London, England: Chatto & Windus.

Al-Sharif, W. (2004). Witchcraft and the persecution of women. Retrieved from                 http://www.archive.org/details/WitchcraftAndThePersecutionOfWomen

Bailey, M.D. (2003a). Battling demons: witchcraft, heresy and reform in the late Middle Ages. University Park, PA: Pennsylvania State University Press.

Bailey, M.D. (2003b). Historical dictionary of witchcraft. Lanham, MA: The Scarecrow Press Inc.

Bever, E. (2008). The realities of witchcraft and popular magic in early modern Europe. Basingstoke,   England: Palgrave Macmillan.

Bonewits, I. (2001). Witchcraft: a concise guide or which witch is which? Miami, FL: Earth Religions Press.

Buckland, R. (1986). Buckland’s complete book of witchcraft. Woodbury, MN: Llewellyn Publications.

Campbell, J.P. (1986). Popular culture in the Middle Ages. Madison, WI: Popular Press.

Colp, R.  (2000). History of psychiatry. In Sadock, B.J & Sadock, V.A. (eds.), Comprehensive text book of psychiatry. (7th edition). Baltimore, MD.: Lippincott, Williams & Wilkins. 

Darton, K. (1999). Notes on the history of mental health care. Mind: London. Retrieved from                 http://www.mind.org.uk/Information/Factsheets/History+of+mental+health/Notes+on+the+History+of+Mental+Health+Care.htm

Dock, L.L. (1920). A short history of nursing from the earliest times to the present day. New York, NY: G.P. Putnam’s Sons.

Elder, R., Evans, K., & Nizette, D. (2005). Psychiatric and mental health nursing. Marrickville, Australia: Elsevier Australia.

Ellerbe, H. (1995). The dark side of Christian history. Berkeley, CA: Morningstar Books.

Fletcher, R. (1896). The witches’ pharmacopoeia. Baltimore, MD: The Friedenwald Co.

Flinn, F.K. (2007). Encyclopedia of Catholicism. New York, NY: Facts on File Inc.

Fulford, B., Thornton, T., & Graham, G. (2006).  Oxford textbook of philosophy and psychiatry. Oxford, England: Oxford University Press.

Gaskill, M. (2000). Crime and mentalities in early modern England. Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press.

Golden, R.M. (Ed.) (2006). Encyclopedia of witchcraft: the western tradition. Santa Barbara, CA: ABC-Clio Inc.

Guiley, R.E. (2008). The encyclopedia of witches, witchcraft and Wicca. (3rd edition). New York, NY: Facts on File Inc.

Gurses, D. (1997). The Satanic ingredients in the seventeenth century witchcraft debate. Unpublished Master’s thesis, Bylkent University, Ankara, Turkey.

Harrison, M. (1975). The roots of witchcraft. New York, NY: Lyle Stewart.

Herzig, T. (2006). Witches, saints and heretics. Magic, Ritual & Witchcraft  1, 1, 24-55.

Hills, F.L. (1901). Psychiatry – ancient, medieval and modern. The Popular Science Monthly 59, 3, 31-48.

Hinshaw, S.P.  (2007). The mark of shame: stigma of mental illness and an agenda for change. Oxford, England: Oxford University Press.

Hoyt, C.A. (1989). Witchcraft. (2nd edition). Carbondale and Edwardsville, IL: Southern Illinois University Press.

Jackson, L. (1995). Witches, wives and mothers: witchcraft persecution and women’s confessions in seventeenth-century England. Women’s History Review 4, 1: 63-84.

James VI (1597). Daemonologie. Edinburgh, Scotland.

Jones, K. (1972). History of the mental health services. Balmain, Australia; Law Book Company of Australasia.

Kamen, H. (2000). Who’s who in Europe 1450-1750. London, England: Routledge.

Levack, B.P (Ed.) (2004). The witchcraft sourcebook. New York, NY: Routledge.

Lewis, J.R. (1999). Witchcraft today: an encyclopedia of Wiccan and neopagan traditions. Santa Barbara, CA: ABC-Clio Inc.

Mackay, C. (1841). Extraordinary popular delusions and the madness of crowds. New York, NY:   Harmony Books.

Mackay, C. (2009). The hammer of witches: a complete translation of the Malleus Maleficarum. Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press.

Maxwell-Stuart, P.G. (2001). Witchcraft in Europe and the New World, 1400-1800. Basingstoke, England: Palgrave.

McBrien, R.P. (2006). The pocket guide to the popes. London, England: Harper Collins.

Millon, T. (2004). Masters of the mind: exploring the story of mental illness from ancient times to the new millennium. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons Inc.

Nemec, J. (1974). Witchcraft and medicine. U.S Department of Health, Education and Welfare. Retrieved from http://www.nlm.nih.gov/hmd/pdf/witchcraft.pdf

Notestein, W. (1911). A history of witchcraft in England from 1558 to 1718. Washington: American Historical Association.

Pollan, M. (2001). The botany of desire: a plant's-eye view of the world. New York, NY: Random House.

Porter, R. (2002). Madness: a brief history. Oxford, England: Oxford University Press.

Pugh, R.J.M. (2001). The Deil’s ain: the story of witch persecution in Scotland. Balerno, Scotland: Harlaw Heritage.

Regis, E. (1894). A practical manual of mental medicine. (2nd edition). Utica, NY: American Journal of Insanity.

Rush, A.J. (1988). Clinical diagnosis of mood disorders. Clinical Chemistry 34, 5: 813-821.

Schuler, R.W. (n.d.). The persecution of women as witches. Retrieved  from http://www.the-night.net/witches/persecution.htm

Scot, R. (1584). The discoverie of witchcraft. From 1886 reprint. London, England: Elliot Stock.

Simpson, J., & Roud, S. (2000). A dictionary of English folklore. Oxford, England: Oxford University Press.

Slattery, E. (1994). To prevent a "Shipwreck of Souls": Johann Weyer and "De Praestigiis Daemonum." Essays in History 36, 83-90. Retrieved from http://etext.virginia.edu/journals/EH/EH36/slattery1.html

Stearne, J. (1648). A confirmation and discovery of witchcraft. London, England: William Wilson.

Summers, M. (1926). The history of witchcraft and demonology. London, England: Kegan Paul, Trench, Trubner & Co.

Toivo, R.M. (2005). Women at stake: interpretations of women’s role in witchcraft and witch-hunts since the early 20th century to the present. Retrieved from http://www.historians.ie/women/sydneypaperi-raisa.pdf

Tuke, D.H. (1882). Chapters in the history of the insane in the British Isles. London, England: Kegan Paul, Trench & Co.

Tuke, D.H. (1892). A dictionary of psychological medicine. Philadelphia, PA: P. Blakiston Son & Co.

Vandermeersch, P. (1991). The victory of psychiatry over demonology: the origin of the nineteenth century myth. History of Psychiatry 2, 8: 351-363.

Williams, H. (1865). The superstitions of witchcraft. London, England: Longman, Green, Longman, Roberts & Green.

Zimmermann, D., & Gleason, K.A. (2000). The complete idiot’s guide to Wicca and witchcraft. Indianapolis, IN: Alpha Books.




No comments:

Post a Comment